Ex parte BONUTTI - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-4021                                                          
          Application 08/289,300                                                      



          movement along a tubular support arm 30 via a stud 42 which                 
          extends through a longitudinal slot 43 in the arm.  The armrest             
          element can be fixed with respect to the slot by means of a wing            
          nut 44 threaded onto the free end of the stud.                              


                    Rogers discloses a display rack comprising an upright             
          tubular supporting post 6, a bearing 12 adjustably disposed                 
          within the post, and a rod 9 rotatably received by the post and             
          resting on the bearing.  The position of the bearing is fixed by            
          a set screw 13 which extends through a slot 7 in the post.                  
          Rogers teaches that this construction allows the rod 9 to be                
          vertically adjusted with respect to the post to accommodate the             
          display of articles having various lengths (see page 1, lines 51            
          through 63).                                                                
                    In explaining the first of the rejections on appeal,              
          the examiner concludes that it would have been obvious to one of            
          ordinary skill in the art “to make the support member of Van                
          Seenus rotatable as shown in Danziger in order to make it easier            
          of [sic, for] a user to enter and exit the seat” (final                     
          rejection, page 2), and “to connect the armrest to the support of           
          [the] modified Van Seenus [armrest assembly] by a slot in the               


                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007