Ex parte YAMAGAMI et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 95-0355                                                          
          Application 08/022,561                                                      


                    & 6), but does [sic, do] not teach that the                       
                    previously formed offset information 4 is                         
                    the frame synch [sic, sync] signals. The                          
                    reference actually teaches that the offset                        
                    information 4 is the frame address                                
                    information. However, Rijnsburger discloses                       
                    in reference to figs. 3a-c that the synch                         
                    [sic, sync] signals can be previously                             
                    formed offset information, in the same                            
                    field of endeavor, for the purpose of                             
                    increasing the information capacity of the                        
                    recording medium.                                                 
                    It would have been obvious to one having                          
                    ordinary skill in the art at the time the                         
                    invention was made to further include the                         
                    frame synch [sic, sync] signals of Ogawa et                       
                    al. within [sic, with] the information 4                          
                    previously formed as offset information on                        
                    the recording medium, as taught by                                
                    Rijnsburger. A practitioner in the art                            
                    would have been motivated to do this in                           
                    order to further increase the information                         
                    capacity of the recording medium.                                 
                                        * * *                                         
                    By stating that the frame sync signals                            
                    would be included within the information 4                        
                    previously formed as offset information,                          
                    the examiner was merely alleging that it                          
                    would have been obvious to additionally                           
                    form the sync signals as offset                                   
                    information. [Answer, pages 2-4.]                                 


                 With particular regard to the claimed step of utilizing              
          a single demodulating and decoding circuit to demodulate and                

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007