Ex parte KAWATA - Page 3


          Appeal No. 95-1516                                                          
          Application No. 07/672,497                                                  

          control the amount of current individually for each pattern                 
          detected.                                                                   
               We will respond to appellant’s points in order:                        

          1. As our decision indicated at the top of page 11, we did                  
          take the claimed “density correction circuit” into account,                 
          identifying such as being taught by Suzuki.  Clearly, encoder               
          43                                                                          
          in Suzuki is the density correction circuit since it controls               
          the laser beam intensity in order to prevent thickening of a                
          black fine line [see column 4, lines 12-19 of Suzuki].  The                 
          encoder 43 outputs a signal S in accordance with correction                 
          density data selected by a density selective circuit [i.e.,                 
          nine pixel data outputs from the pixel X and adjacent pixels                
          A-H are supplied to the encoder-column 4, lines 12-14 of                    
          Suzuki].  When this teaching of providing for a sharper, finer              
          image is taken together with the teachings of Hirane and                    
          Zeise, for the reasons recited at pages 10-11 of our decision,              
          the artisan would clearly have arrived at the claimed subject               
          matter.                                                                     
          It is true that Suzuki does not show the corrected                          
          picture signal data being input to a shift register in the LED              
          head, as claimed.  However, Suzuki is employed to show the                  
          obviousness of using a line memory, a density selective                     


                                          3                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007