Ex parte DANNENBERG - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-3673                                                          
          Application 07/935,762                                                      


          conventional in the art as recognized by Bruggemann anyway in the           
          discussion beginning at column 1, line 17.                                  
               There, it was conventional in the art to test such electro-            
          mechanical/analogue-display instruments per se by the use of a              
          simulated measured value and determining whether the                        


          corresponding displayed value was obtained.  This, by necessity,            
          required a sweeping action of the type claimed to have been                 
          instituted.                                                                 
               On the other hand, the bulk of the disclosure in Bruggemann            
          is not concerned with such types of displays but only segmented             
          types of displays comprised of liquid crystals.  A significant              
          portion of the details of Bruggemann’s disclosure relates to                
          testing each of the individual segments of the liquid crystal               
          displays represented by various display elements 1 to 7 in Figure           
          1 by means of the testing action depicted in Figures 3b through             
          3d.  Another portion of the testing action in Bruggemann is                 
          related to testing certain functional elements or operational               
          elements of circuitry therein as depicted by the numeric                    
          representation only shown in Figure 3a.  See for example the                
          discussion beginning at the bottom of column 5 and numeric                  



                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007