Ex parte COOMBS et al. - Page 29




          Appeal No. 95-4152                                                          
          Application 08/042,044                                                      

          as a substitute for his or her own vision would need the                    
          virtual image to match the real view image as closely as                    
          possible to be able to walk around and function successfully.               
          For the reasons stated above, we sustain the rejection of                   
          claims 12 and 24.                                                           


          Claim 16 -- Hanson, Coombs, and Rodway                                      
               Claim 16 recites fire protective insulated jackets for                 
          covering the camera and the display.  The examiner finds that               
          Rodway teaches a thermally insulated jacket 109 for protecting              
          a camera from intense heat of a basic oxygen furnace (BOF)                  
          (col. 4, lines 37-56) and concludes that it would have been                 
          obvious to cover a camera and display with insulated jackets                
          to protect them from heat if used in an environment of extreme              
          heat (EA10).  We agree.  In our opinion, one skilled in the                 
          art adapting the camera and display system of Hanson to a fire              
          fighting environment (one of the different uses taught for                  
          Hanson's system at col. 15, line 39) had sufficient knowledge               
          both to recognize the problem that the camera and display                   
          would be exposed to high temperatures and flames and the                    
          solution of using fire protective insulated jackets.                        

                                       - 29 -                                         





Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007