Ex parte MAYER - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-4373                                                         
          Application 07/917,108                                                     


               Appellant argues on page 3 of the supplemental brief that             
          these amendments to the specification are simply inserting the             
          language found in the original claims.  Appellant points out that          
          original claim 1 recites "characterized in that the threshold              
          value for the next original image following the original image is          
          set so high that ...."  Appellant points out on page 4 of the              
          supplemental brief that original claim 3 recites "for those                
          images in which the threshold was set high."  Appellant argues             
          that the amendment to the specification corresponds in substance,          
          if not identically, to the recitation appearing in the original            
          claims and therefore cannot constitute new matter.                         


               The issue before us is whether the inventor had possession,           
          as of the filing date of the application relied on, of the                 
          specific subject matter later claimed by him.  We note that                
          appellant’s original claims are to be considered as the original           
          disclosure as filed and are to be considered with the entire               
          filing in our determination of whether the inventor had                    
          possession at the time of the filing date of the application.              
               We find that the above amendments to the specification                
          correspond in substance to the recitations found in the original           
          claims as filed on the application date and thereby Appellant did          

                                          6                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007