Ex parte HORTON - Page 5




                Appeal No. 95-4852                                                                                                            
                Application 08/224,090                                                                                                        


                this limitation (see page 4 in the answer).  The appellant,                                                                   
                tacitly acknowledging that Woten’s auger 18 conveys insulation                                                                
                material in one direction toward an exit opening, argues that                                                                 
                                 Wooten [sic, Woten] recognizes that at least in                                                              
                         some operating conditions, a screw auger tends to                                                                    
                         compact the material, rather than dispersing the material                                                            
                         as required for the first means.  This is set forth in                                                               
                         detail in column 1 at lines 46-66 of Wooten [sic].                                                                   
                         Thus, the “means” disclosed in Wooten [sic] does not                                                                 
                         perform the identical function called for with respect                                                               
                         to the “first means” in claim 20 [brief, page 4,                                                                     
                         emphasis in the original].                                                                                           
                         Woten does in fact discuss the problem of auger-induced                                                              
                compaction in insulating machines at column 1, lines 46 through                                                               
                66.  Contrary to the appellant’s implication, however, the                                                                    
                particular insulating machine disclosed by Woten is designed to                                                               
                eliminate this problem.  To this end, the Woten machine includes                                                              
                a number of rotating components such as a jogger 28, a circulator                                                             
                22, the aforementioned auger 18 and a granulator 7 which keep                                                                 
                loose fill insulation material in a state of constant motion and                                                              
                agitation to separate or “disperse”  the individual particles4                                                                  







                         4 Webster’s New Collegiate Dictionary (G. & C. Merriam Co.                                                           
                1977) defines term “disperse” as meaning “to cause to break up”.                                                              
                                                                    -5-                                                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007