Ex parte FROESSL - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-1190                                                            
          Application 07/950,177                                                        

          characters; and storing the signals representative of images                  
          of ambiguous characters for use in retrieval of documents in                  
          which the ambiguous characters appeared."                                     
               The examiner states (FR7; EA5):                                          
               Where the patterns of electrical signals forming lexicons                
               of images of both character fonts and non-character                      
               shapes stored in the computer memory contains ambiguous                  
               characters for use in retrieval of documents in which the                
               ambiguous character appeared (refer to column 15, line 64                
               through column 16, line 12).  The thinning or thickening                 
               of characters in memory generates distorted characters                   
               which corresponds to applicant's ambiguous characters.                   
               Although the initial capital letter and the final period                 
          make the first sentence above a typographical sentence, it is                 
          not a grammatical sentence because the word "where" turns the                 
          words into a dependent clause--a fragment.  The idea intended                 
          to be conveyed is incomplete.  We have read Katsuyama,                        
          column 15, line 64 through column 16, line 12, but fail to                    
          understand how it anticipates the claimed steps.  The                         
          referenced portion of Katsuyama discusses carrying out a                      
          thickening/thinning operation governed by a parameter F and a                 
          magnification/reduction operation governed by a scale                         
          parameter S.  The combination of parameters which provides the                
          smallest "city block distance" are the optimum parameters for                 
          character recognition.  Katsuyama says nothing about what                     
                                         - 4 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007