Ex parte FROESSL - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-1190                                                            
          Application 07/950,177                                                        

          the correction algorithm" (EA12).  Appellant responds that                    
          "[i]f this is not a new ground of rejection, it is certainly a                
          total rephrasing of prior rejections" (RBr2).  We agree with                  
          appellant that the Final Rejection did not address the                        
          specific limitations of claims 22 and 25, much less in this                   
          specific way.  Nevertheless, we consider the examiner's new                   
          reasons to be unpersuasive.                                                   
               The examiner compares the limitations of claim 17 with                   
          claims 22 and 25 (EA9-12).  The first two limitations of                      
          claims 17, 22, and 25, establishing stored patterns and                       
          comparing signals, are similar and are not disputed as being                  
          in Katsuyama.                                                                 
               The third limitation in claim 17 of "identifying signals                 
          . . . for which no match is found as ambiguous characters" is                 
          not found in Katsuyama as discussed supra.  The third                         
          limitation of claims 22 and 25 of "identifying signals . . .                  
          which represent numerals" is found in Katsuyama because                       
          Katsuyama identifies both letters and numerals.                               
               The fourth limitation of claim 17 of "storing the signals                
          representative of images of ambiguous characters for use in                   
          retrieval of documents in which the ambiguous characters                      

                                         - 8 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007