Ex parte THOMAS - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-1323                                                          
          Application 08/295,118                                                      



                    Appellant's argument that the integrally molded tray              
          of Hinds lacks "drive member receiving groove means" and                    
          "alignment means," each defined on the bottom surface of the                
          plant tray by portions of the intermediate walls and portions               
          of the side walls that make up the molded tray and open-ended               
          plant cells therein, is simply not understood.  It is clear to              
          us that in an arrangement like that seen generally in Figure 1              
          of Hinds, but with square plant cells as described on page 2,               
          lines 40-45, and square flange portions extending around each               
          of the plant cell drain openings as explained in the paragraph              
          bridging pages 1  and 2 of Hinds, the tray therein would have               
          a plurality of (e.g., three) longitudinally extending                       
          generally "U-shaped" grooves intermediate the four rows of                  
          plant cell openings and a partial groove extending about the                
          periphery of the tray, and a plurality of (i.e., nine)                      
          generally "U-shaped" grooves positioned in perpendicular                    
          relationship to the longitudinally extending grooves.  All of               
          these grooves in the tray of Hinds would be defined or formed               
          on the bottom surface of the tray by "portions of" the                      
          intermediate walls and "portions of" the side walls that                    

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007