Ex parte HAUK - Page 2




          Appeal No. 96-3463                                                         
          Application 08/514,835                                                     


               The appellant's invention pertains a power jaw apparatus              
          for applying high torques to sections of threadedly connected              
          pipe.  Of particular importance is the provision of a pair of              
          cooperating toothed pipe-gripping dies wherein one die is mounted          
          for rotation through a relatively large angle and the other die            
          is either (1) fixed or (2) mounted for rotation through a                  
          relatively small angle.  According to the appellant's                      
          specification, this arrangement (1) achieves the advantages of             
          (a) providing "more stability" than the examiner's primary                 
          reference to Hauk and (b) maximizes the extension of the power             
          cylinder (see the paragraph bridging pages 12 and 13).  The                
          appellant's specification further states that the required                 
          arrangement (2) provides the above-noted advantages (a) and (b)            
          and, in addition, provides the advantage of (c) "spreading" the            
          load over different teeth (see pages 13 and 14).  Independent              
          claims 12 and 15 are further illustrative of the appealed subject          
          matter and copies thereof may be found in the appendix to the              
          appellant's brief.                                                         
               The references relied on by the examiner are:                         
          Wheeler                  2,959,996           Nov. 15, 1960                 
          Inoue                    4,706,528           Nov. 17, 1987                 
          Schulze-Beckinghausen    5,044,232           Sep.  3, 1991                 
          Hauk                     5,060,542           Oct. 29, 1991                 


                                          2                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007