Ex parte BLONGREN - Page 6




          Appeal No.97-0582                                                           
          Application 08/179,926                                                      


               Upon a closer review of Portanova, we fail to find that                
          Portanova suggests to those skilled in the art to provide an                
          additional CISC decoder.  Portanova teaches in column 1, lines              


          15-23, that although the development of CISC software is simpler            
          and easier to use, the CISC hardware requires the use of very               
          large scale integration resulting in a highly complex                       
          microprocessor hardware design.   Portanova further teaches in              
          column 1, lines 24-42, that RISC systems require simpler                    
          microprocessors, but require more functions to be done in                   
          software.  In column 3, lines 44-56, Portanova teaches that the             
          object of their invention is to provide a simple RISC                       
          architecture which eases the hardwired decoding of instructions             
          which in turn speeds control paths but also can emulate CISC                
          instruction sets.  Portanova teaches in column 4, lines 18-34,              
          that the Portanova RISC architecture responds to CISC                       
          instructions by addressing a corresponding one of a plurality of            
          groups of RISC instructions, each corresponding to one of the               
          complex instructions.  Thus, Portanova teaches that the same RISC           
          architecture may be use to process a CISC instruction so that the           
          simpler and faster RISC hardware may be used for both                       
          instructions sets.  From this teaching, Portanova leads those               

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007