WANG V. TUCHOLSKI - Page 59





          Interference No. 103,036                                                    



                              In order for this embodiment to be operable             
                    when applied to the side of the dry cell battery                  
                    disclosed in the specification and drawings, the                  
                    construction of the battery strength indicator,                   
                    including the nonconductive layers, must be such to               
                    permit sufficient heat generated by the reduced                   
                    section conductive area 65 to flow to the color                   
                    indicator material to cause a color change.  Heat                 
                    generated by the reduced section conductive area 65               
                    is within the sealed chamber or zone 66 adjacent to               
                    nonconductive layers 30 and 32, and will naturally                
                    desire to flow in all directions from reduced cross               
                    sectional conductive area 65, unless somehow                      
                    constrained.  In this instance, the clear function of             
                    nonconductive layers 30 and 32 is with regard to heat             
                    flow to ensure that the heat generated by the reduced             
                    conductive layer 65 is able to raise the temperature              
                    of the color indicating, heat sensitive material 70.              
                    The only way this can be accomplished is if layers 30             
                    and 32 are thermally nonconductive. [Emphasis in the              
                    original.]                                                        
          Note that Alan Salkind, one of the party Cataldi's witnesses                
          called by the party Wang et al., testified that he presumed that            
          the nonconductive layer is both thermally nonconductive as well             
          as electrically nonconductive.  BR 2903.  Dr. Feder, an expert              
          testifying on behalf of the party Cataldi et al., testified with            
          respect to BX 5, which is directly analogous to the thermal                 
          battery strength indicator described in the Burroughs patent,               
          that nonconductive would normally mean either electrically or               
          thermally nonconductive  BR 3938 to 3939.                                   

                                           -59-                                       





Page:  Previous  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007