BARKER V. ELSON et al. - Page 19




          Interference No. 103,146                                                    



                    Barker has conceded that the flow-through housing                 
          embodiment with the probe eyelet extending substantially                    
          across the lumen was conceived by Cook, one of the senior                   
          party inventors, by at least December 24, 1980.  Barker brief               
          at 27. That day, Cook drew by hand and dated a sketch of an                 
          invention within the scope of the count.  EX-27; ER168-172.                 
          Elson                                                                       
          exhibit 10, EX-10, is an engineering or formal drawing                      
          prepared for manufacturing a prototype of an embodiment within              
          the scope of the count.  The drawing EX-10 has a date of                    
          February 9, 1981.  The drawing is described in the testimony                
          of Chin, Switzer and Cook, the former two witnesses being non-              
          inventors.                                                                  
                    The Record further establishes that a prototype of                
          the Elson closed-loop injectate system was undergoing testing               
          by March 1981.  Anita Switzer testified that she performed                  
          bench tests of a prototype of the invention before March 26,                
          1981.   EX-58; ER441-446.                                                   
                    Proof of actual reduction to practice requires                    
          demonstration that the embodiment relied upon as evidence of                
          priority actually worked for its intended purpose.  Newkirk,                
                                          19                                          





Page:  Previous  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007