Ex parte PICARD et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 95-3800                                                          
          Application 08/046,109                                                      


          An I/O request in Albright is considered to be “foreign” if it              
          occurs in a program originally written for a second system but              
          is being run on a first system.  Since a program in Albright                
          is either written for the first system or is not written for                
          the first system, all the I/O instructions within a given                   
          program would be foreign or not foreign as far as Albright’s                
          system is concerned.  Therefore, if a program written for the               
          second system is run on Albright’s first system, all the I/O                
          requests would be treated as “foreign” requests and would lead              
          to the execution of special I/O code each time such an I/O                  
          instruction is executed.  In our view, this operation of                    
          Albright is sufficient to fully meet the invention as recited               
          in claim 13.  The fact that Albright can also execute programs              
          which are not “foreign” does not alter the fact that once a                 
          “foreign” program is loaded into Albright’s system, the                     
          invention as recited in claim 13 is fully met.                              
          Therefore, we sustain the examiner’s rejection of                           
          claim 13 as anticipated by the disclosure of Albright.  Since               
          appellants have not separately argued any of claims 14-22,                  
          these claims fall with claim 13.                                            


                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007