Ex parte KUHNE - Page 9




          Appeal No. 95-4791                                                           
          Application 08/034,849                                                       
          subjects infected with all types of retroviruses, but also (3)               
          the various subsidiary forms of the HIV virus infections in                  
          humans infected with the various subsidiary forms of the HIV                 
          virus.  We disagree for the following reasons.                               
               First, we find that the prior art direction to (1)                      
          topically administer stabilized chlorite solutions prior to,                 
          or in the course of, surgery as an anti-infectant,                           
          disinfectant, or antiseptic, (2) topically or intravenously                  
          administer stabilized chlorite solutions as an antitumor agent               
          in conjunction with radio- or chemotherapy, and (3)                          
          intravenously administer stabilized chlorite solutions for the               
          treatment of “infectious conditions caused by parasites,                     
          fungi, bacteria, viruses and/or mycoplasmas,” reasonably would               
          not have led persons having ordinary skill in the art to                     
          expect success in treating HIV viral infection by parenteral                 
          administration of stabilized chlorite solutions to an infected               
          subject without some objective evidence indicative of                        
          potential success.  The only objective evidence of potential                 
          success in parenterally treating HIV virus infection that the                
          examiner presents relates to the treatment of subjects                       
          infected with bacteria or subjects undergoing radio- or                      
          chemotherapy for malignant tumors.  The only objective                       
                                          9                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007