Ex parte BONISSONE et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 96-0361                                                          
          Application 08/288,154                                                      

          operation of the fuzzy logic rule base," as claimed.  The                   
          rules in rule base 700 are not employed until the minimum                   
          comparator 500.  The examiner has failed to establish a prima               
          facie case of anticipation.                                                 
               Nevertheless, for reasons not stated by the examiner, we               
          find that Basehore appears to teach the claimed invention.                  
               Basehore discloses that the minimum comparator 500                     
          processes the fuzzified input signals in accordance with a                  
          predetermined fuzzy logic rule selected from the rule memory                
          700 (col. 6, line 48 to col. 7, line 4).  The maximum                       
          comparator 600 identifies the rule which has the maximum value              
          for the minimum term rule (col. 7, lines 11-16):  "The                      
          identified rule, selected as having the highest overall degree              
          of correlation and, therefore, the optimum output, is                       
          addressed from the rule memory 700 and the corresponding rule               
          output is provided to an output register 800" (emphasis                     
          added).  Basehore states (col. 7, lines 18-19):  "The output                
          register 800 modifies the existing (or initial) output on the               
          basis of the rule output provided."  The output register is                 
          shown in figure 10.  Basehore states (col. 15, lines 29-33):                
          "The MAX RULE signal from the maximum comparator 600 is                     

                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007