Ex parte JEON et al. - Page 15




          Appeal No. 96-0974                                                          
          Application 08/024,299                                                      


          receive control signals (flags) from the operation monitoring               
          channel 14 (col. 4, lines 11-14).  As is apparent from the                  
          figure, the receiving processing terminal 20 includes similar               
          fault detection and rerouting circuitry.                                    
               The examiner, after asserting that "Kohno teaches the use              
          of a multi-core cable" but "does not teach the remaining                    
          elements of this claim, reads appellant’s claimed                           
          "transmitting data processing means" on the "transmitting data              
          processing terminal at the first termination point" recited in              
          Lebby’s claim 1 (at col. 5, line 61), reads appellants’                     
          claimed "receiving microprocessor" on the "receiving, data                  
          processing terminal at the second termination point" recited                
          in Lebby’s claim 1 (at col. 5, line 38), and reads appellants’              
          claimed "transmitting demultiplexer" and "receiving                         
          multiplexer" on the "controllable connecting circuitry"                     
          recited in Libby’s claim 1 (at col. 6, lines 13-22).  The                   
          examiner concludes the rejection by stating:                                
                    It would have been obvious to anyone having                       
                    ordinary skill in the art at the time the                         
                    invention was made to have included the features                  
                    displayed by Lebby et al. in the system                           
                    disclosed by Kohno since the microprocessor                       
                    based data processing equipment affords                           
                    flexibility and speed to the transmission and                     
                                       - 15 -                                         





Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007