Ex parte LIPSEY - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-1389                                                          
          Application No. 07/925,615                                                  


          stream of air coming from a cotton gin and discharging the                  
          separated trash into the inlet of the conveyor means, and (6)               
          fluid means for adding a fluid to the cotton gin trash as the               
          cotton gin trash is received in the inlet of the conveyor                   
          means.                                                                      
               As to (1), the examiner cites Shelef as disclosing that                
          it is conventional in the art to compost material in piles                  
          wherein the piled compost material is provided on a porous                  
          support surface.  The examiner contends that it would have                  
          been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art in view of                 
          Shelef to compost the material of Pinckard on a porous support              
          surface “for the known and expected control of the composting               
          pile which is provided by the porous support surface” (answer,              
          page 4).  Concerning (2) and (3), the examiner cites Malmström              
          as teaching a screw auger device for piling material which                  
          includes a conveyor means 15 that is supported in a horizontal              
          position above a surface by a support post.  The examiner                   
          contends that it would have been obvious to employ a device as              
          disclosed by Malmström “for the known and expected result of                
          making piles of materials as required by the primary reference              
          of Shelef [Pinckard?]” (answer, pages 4-5).  Concerning (4),                
                                         -4-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007