Appeal No. 1996-3276 Application 07/978,518 pulse-string signals, wherein each one of said plural groups of said pulse-string signals represents a message, and wherein there is a predetermined normal maximum number N of pulses 1MAX in each said group of said pulse-string signals and a predetermined normal minimum idle time T between successive MIN ones of said groups of said pulse-string signals, said monitoring circuit comprising: counting means receiving said communication signal, for counting a number of pulses in each said group of said pulse-string signals of said communication signal, and when said counted number of pulses exceeds a predetermined maximum number of pulses which is equal to at least said maximum number N for 1MAX’ outputting an abnormal condition signal which represents an abnormal condition of said communication device; and idle time measuring means, receiving a reference clock signal and being responsive to said communication signal, for measuring an amount of idle time between successive ones of said groups of said pulse-string signals of said communication signal by counting a number of pulses of said reference clock signal, and for resetting said counting means when said measured idle time exceeds a predetermined minimum amount of idle time which is at most said minimum idle time T . MIN The references relied on by the Examiner are: Matsuura et al. (Matsuura) 4,555,702 Nov. 26, 1985 Ihara et al. (Ihara) 4,623,884 Nov. 18, 1986 Class B Data Communication Network Interface-SAE J1850, Aug., 1991 (APA) Claims 1 and 11 to 25 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 over Ihara, Matsuura and APA. 3Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007