Ex parte NILSSEN - Page 36




          Appeal No. 96-3618                                                          
          Application 08/004,598                                                      

          into an [sic] portable cordless entity operable to function as              
          a cordless base station for the cordless-cellular telephone."               
          It is noted that claim 27 only requires the base station to be              
          "cordless" in the sense of having no attached power cord,                   
          there are no limitations that would require it to be cordless               
          in the sense of having no hardwire connection to a telephone                
          line.                                                                       
               Stoodley discloses that a cordless telephone base unit                 
          has a power supply and "[t]he power supply may be arranged to               
          draw power from a utility outlet, and may optionally be                     
          provided with a battery backup" (col. 7, lines 30-32).                      
          Manifestly, with a battery backup, the base unit can be                     
          operated without a cord.  We agree with the Examiner that it                
          would have been obvious to provide a battery in the base                    
          station of Gillig "in order to provide power to the base                    
          station in the event of a [sic] electrical outage of the power              
          company" (EA12) and also because a battery would allow the                  
          base station to be moved around without the restriction of a                
          cord.  We do not find where Appellant traversed this rejection              
          of claim 27.  The rejection of claim 27 is sustained.                       

          15.  Claims 30, 46, and 61:  § 103(a) over Gillig and Yorita                
                                       - 36 -                                         





Page:  Previous  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007