Ex parte NILSSEN - Page 41




          Appeal No. 96-3618                                                          
          Application 08/004,598                                                      


          17.  Claims 1, 5, 66, 67, 71-74, 76, and 77:                                
          § 103(a) over Gillig and Schellinger                                        
               Gillig discloses the limitations of claim 1 except for                 
          the limitation of "a second base transceiver functional to                  
          provide telephonic connection with a cellular telephone system              
          independent of the first base transceiver."  The Examiner                   
          relies on Schellinger, figure 1.  Figure 1 shows a cellular                 
          cordless portable telephone 101 may be in communication with a              
          cordless base station 115 in a home or office, one of several               
          cellular base stations 105, 107 in a cellular telephone system              
          103, or "a microcellular base station 113, which is a cellular              
          adjunct cell having lower power and limited capabilities but                
          providing public radiotelephone service to distinct areas such              
          as shopping malls, airports, etc." (col. 3, lines 14-17).  The              
          Examiner states that the placement of the microcellular base                
          station is arbitrary and concludes that "it would have been                 
          obvious . . . to include both the microcellular base station                
          and the cordless base station within the same housing . . .                 
          because it would allow the two base stations to share common                
          elements (and space) and reduce the cost and use of materials               
          of the two base stations" (SEA16).                                          

                                       - 41 -                                         





Page:  Previous  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007