Ex parte NILSSEN - Page 43




          Appeal No. 96-3618                                                          
          Application 08/004,598                                                      

               Claim 66 recites a battery operated portable structure                 
          having two transceivers.  Neither Gillig nor Schellinger                    
          discloses a battery operated structure and we do not find                   
          where the Examiner addresses this limitation.  Claim 66                     
          further recites that the structure effectuates communication                
          between a cellular base station and the structure, and between              
          the structure and a portable cordless telephone instrument.                 
          Assuming, arguendo, that the combination of Gillig and                      
          Schellinger is proper, the microcellular system would                       
          communicate with the TELCO over hardwired telephone lines, not              
          a cellular base station as claimed.  For these two reasons,                 
          the rejection of claim 66 is reversed.                                      
               Claims 67 is are similar to claim 66 and the rejection of              
          claim 67 and its dependent claims 71 and 72 is reversed for                 
          the same two reasons.                                                       
               Claims 73 and 77 recite connect means to effectuate                    
          communication between a cordless telephone instrument, the                  
          cordless base station, a cellular telephone instrument, and a               
          cellular base station, which is similar to the cellular                     
          cordless scheme in claim 66.  Assuming, arguendo, that the                  
          combination of Gillig and Schellinger is proper, it does not                

                                       - 43 -                                         





Page:  Previous  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007