Ex parte HERROD - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-4029                                                          
          Application 08/386,604                                                      



          the screen ownership area and processing the window hierarchy.              
                                                                                     
          Anthias discloses in column 7, lines 46 through 65, that their              
          invention overcomes this problem by maintaining an ownership                
          priority list.  In column 8, lines 4 through 57, Anthias                    
          discloses a multiple window display system which includes a                 
          display device and a screen ownership area pointing to the                  
          identity of the window which is to contribute the data for                  
          each display area of the display device.  An ordered list is                
          maintained of the active windows in the priority order                      
          thereof.  Anthias discloses that the lowest priority window is              
          first written into the display area and then each higher                    
          priority window is then overwritten with this data.  Anthias'               
          disclosure of the ownership priority list is not directed to                
          maintaining a list of modified graphic orders as claimed by                 
          the Appellant.  Anthias, on the other hand, teaches a list of               
          ownership priority which is only used to determine the                      
          priority of the window, not to the objects within the window.               
                    In view of the above, we find that Anthias fails to               
          teach all the limitations of Appellant's claims 1, 2, and 7                 

                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007