Ex parte RAGHUPATHI et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 97-0139                                                          
          Application No. 08/196,819                                                  


          the examiner cites the "secondary references" to Wong and                   
          Temple for their respective teachings of the use of the                     
          claimed polyvinylacetate polymers as film forming polymers                  
          used in aqueous sizing compositions for glass fibers.                       
               With regard to the relied upon "secondary references,"                 
          Wong discloses that film formers that have been used in                     
          combination include epoxies, polyvinylacetate and polyesters                
          (column 4, lines 65 through 68), and that the combination of                
          film formers improves the handleability or processing                       
          characteristics of the glass fibers (column 4, lines 38                     
          through 41) as well as the strand integrity (column 3, lines                
          30 through 33).  In like manner, Temple discloses the use of                
          an aqueous sizing composition for glass fibers comprising,                  
          inter alia, an epoxy polymer and a polyvinylacetate/silane                  
          copolymer which produces sized glass fibers in chopped form                 
          that have good strength and flow properties which leads to the              
          formation of reinforced thermosetting materials having "good                
          strength" (column 1, lines 7 through 13).                                   
               Based on the known advantages associated with the use of               
          polyvinylacetate polymers in combination with epoxies and                   
          polyester film forming polymers in aqueous sizing compositions              
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007