Ex parte VAN BOKHORST et al. - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1997-0899                                                        
          Application No. 08/127,268                                                  


          has been                                                                    
          received or after a timeout period whereas claim 4 requires                 
          that power be maintained until the next synchronizing message               
          is received [pages 9-10].                                                   
          Although Mabey does teach additional power consumption                      
          approaches such as powering down the receiver at the end of                 
          its reception or by powering down the receiver after a                      
          predetermined time period, these are not the only approaches                
          suggested by Mabey.  Mabey also suggests that a given receiver              
          may be maintained in its active state until the next control                
          period [column 8, lines 2-7].  Since the control periods in                 
          Mabey are the synchronizing messages of the Mabey-Fujiwara                  
          combination, we do not agree with appellants that the                       
          collective teachings of the prior art do not suggest the                    
          maintaining step of claim 4.  Therefore, we sustain the                     
          rejection of claims 4 and 11.                                               
          With respect to the claims of Group V as represented                        
          by claim 6, appellants argue that the prior art does not teach              
          or suggest the transmitting step of claim 6 [reply brief, page              
          10].  Claim 6 recites that source and destination addresses                 
          are included in the traffic indicator messages.  Mabey’s                    
                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007