Ex parte HERMAN - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-1461                                                        
          Application 08/388,915                                                      


          emulsion carrier is identified as either an organic solvent or              
          water.  Ritzer indicates that when the solvent for the binder               
          is water, it is used in large amounts and serves as a carrier               
          for the binder and as a heat transfer fluid to quench the heat              
          of reaction.                                                                
               Kotval is directed to a process for the production of                  
          silicon materials with reduced aluminum impurity levels,                    
          useful for solar panel applications.  In order to reduce the                
          impurities in silicon materials, Kotval teaches that it is                  
          known to treat silicon materials with silicon tetrachloride to              
          reduce the aluminum content (see column 2, lines 40-45).                    
               Whereas Chadwick seeks to convert the high boiling                     
          component to monosilanes, appellant seeks to recover the                    
          silicon particulate from the high boiling component by (A)                  
          initially separating the liquid and particulate components;                 
          (B) washing the particulate component with a solvent having a               
          boiling point lower than the sublimation temperature of the                 
          metal salt to separate the high-boiling silicon containing                  
          compound(s); and then (C) spray drying the particulate                      
          component (our emphasis).                                                   
               In order to establish a prima face case of obviousness,                
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007