Ex parte JOSEPH - Page 7




          Appeal No. 97-1631                                          Page 7           
          Application No. 08/245,267                                                   


          and the indicia, and out of the plane of the indicia, the                    
          masking means carrying at least one coded symbol; ....”                      
          Independent claim 20 specifies inter alia an analogous step of               
          “positioning masking means in the beam intermediate the                      
          scanning means and the indicia, and the masking means being                  
          out of the plane of the indicia, the masking means carrying at               
          least one coded symbol; ....”                                                


               Guthmueller employs a Video Processor Unit (VPU) to                     
          detect and read bar codes.  An optical scanner of the VPU                    
          generates video data representing data written, printed, or                  
          coded  on mail.   A Video Controller processes the video data                
          and then transmits it to a Bar Code Reader (VPUBR).  The VPUBR               
          moves a template mask, Fig. 1, over the scanned video data to                
          find tall and short bars of the code, Col. 2, ll. 19-47, which               
          represent binary ones and zeros, respectively.  Col. 1, ll.                  
          15-17.                                                                       


               Comparison of the claim’s language to the reference’s                   
          teachings evidences that Guthmueller fails to teach or suggest               
          the claimed masking means or the step of positioning it.  The                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007