Ex parte PONTAILLIER et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 97-2621                                                          
          Application 08/432,442                                                      

          distance between G2b and G3 that is a mistake and that the two              
          elements should be much farther apart and therefore the linear              
          projections from G2b actually would not overlap the apertured               
          portion of G3.  The appellants’ conclusion is entirely                      
          arbitrary, since it may well be that the shown distance                     
          between G2b and G3 is correct and it is the other shown                     
          dimensions in Figure 2 that are mistaken.                                   
          In any event, as we have already discussed above, it is                     
          already erroneous to assume that the illustrated dimensions in              
          Figure 2 must match or correspond to the specific numbers                   
          given from the bottom of Chen’s column 6 to the top of column               
          7.  The specific numbers are only that of a single embodiment,              
          while other embodiments are described elsewhere in the                      
          specification.  For instance, from the bottom of column 7 to                
          the top of column 8, it is stated:                                          

                    Conversely, the thickness of the G2a                              
                    should not be so small as to require a slot                       
                    width significantly less than the diameter                        
                    of the G2b aperture 56. Although the width                        
                    of the slot aperture 55 can be less than                          
                    the diameter of the beam forming aperture                         
                    56, when it is made excessively less, the                         
                    mechanical tolerance of the alignment                             
                    between the slot aperture 55 and the beam                         
                    forming aperture 56 becomes critical.                             
                    Experience has shown that with a beam                             
                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007