Ex parte TRINE - Page 2




                 Appeal No. 98-0108                                                                                   Page 2                            
                 Application No. 08/598,795                                                                                                             


                          Appellant’s claimed invention relates to a handle for                                                                         
                 pushing or pulling a cart.  According to claim 1, the only                                                                             
                 independent claim on appeal, the handle comprises a                                                                                    
                 generally horizontally disposed central portion (40) and two                                                                           
                 hand grip sections (46, 48) connected to opposite ends of                                                                              
                 the central portion and extending at obtuse angles from the                                                                            
                 central portion.  Claim 1 recites that the central portion                                                                             
                 and the hand grip portions are in a common plane (i.e., lie                                                                            
                 along a common plane) at an acute angle with respect to a                                                                              
                 vertical plane.  Appellant’s hand grip sections are                                                                                    
                 therefore inclined forwardly in a longitudinal direction and                                                                           
                 also laterally inwardly toward each other.                                                                                             


                          A copy of the appealed claims is appended to appellant’s                                                                      
                 brief.2                                                                                                                                

                          2Dependent claims 3 and 4 recite that each of the hand                                                                        
                 grip sections is attached to the cart.  According to                                                                                   
                 appellant’s specification, however, the hand grip sections                                                                             
                 are not directly connected to the cart.  Instead, they are                                                                             
                 connected to the attachment sections 52 and 56, and the                                                                                
                 attachment sections, in turn, are connected to the cart.  In                                                                           
                 light of this description in the specification, we have                                                                                
                 interpreted the subject matter recited in claims 3 and 4 to                                                                            
                 be broad enough to encompass a structure in which the hand                                                                             
                 grip sections are indirectly connected to the cart through                                                                             







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007