Ex parte TRINE - Page 6




          Appeal No. 98-0108                                       Page 6             
          Application No. 08/598,795                                                  


               As disclosed in column 1, lines 63-68, of the Vom Brauke               
          specification, the hand grip sections 5 are inclined                        
          laterally inwardly toward each other for the advantageous                   
          purpose of allowing an operator to move his hands laterally                 
          inwardly from a collision zone to avoid contact with other                  
          carts or platform carriages as they are called in the Vom                   
          Brauke specification. Such an express suggestion would have                 
          been ample motivation for one of ordinary skill in the art                  
          to incline each of Kazmerchek’s side grip sections laterally                
          inwardly at an acute angle to thereby establish a complement                
          which is an obtuse angle with respect to Kazmerchek’s                       
          horizontal central portion for the purpose of allowing an                   
          operator to move his hands away from a possible collision                   
          zone.                                                                       


               The Kegley reference discloses a handle which is similar               
          to Kazmerchek’s handle and also appellant’s handle in that                  
          it has a central horizontally extending portion 17 and two                  
          side sections 13a and 13b extending downwardly and                          
          rearwardly from opposite ends of the central portion.                       
          Kegley is relevant for its recognition of utilizing the side                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007