Ex parte TRINE - Page 5




          Appeal No. 98-0108                                       Page 5             
          Application No. 08/598,795                                                  


          central portion at what appears to be 90 degree angles                      
          rather than an obtuse angles.  With respect to appealed                     
          claim 1, no other limitations are argued as differences over                
          the Kazmerchek reference.                                                   


               The Vom Brauke reference discloses a push cart handle                  
          having two hand grip sections 5 and a horizontal central                    
          portion 6 in the region between the hand grip sections.  Vom                
          Brauke’s hand grip sections are angled in the same manner as                
          appellant’s hand grip sections in that they not only are                    
          inclined forwardly in a longitudinal direction as shown in                  
          Figure 3, but also are inclined laterally inwardly toward                   
          each other at acute angles B with respect to vertical planes                
          extending parallel to the cart’s longitudinal axis as shown                 
          in Figure 4 of the patent drawings.  The angle B that each                  
          of Vom Brauke’s hand grip sections makes with a vertical,                   
          longitudinally extending plane and the obtuse angle recited                 
          in appealed claim 1 are related in that one is merely the                   
          complement of the other.                                                    










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007