Ex parte TITZ et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-0514                                                        
          Application 08/523,907                                                      


          the interior of the molded article and cracking occurs                      
          therein” (column 4, lines 1-4).  Gomi’s solution to this prior              
          art problem is to carefully select the orientation angle, the               
          orientation order, and the thickness of each layer of the                   
          laminate so that a compressive                                              




          stress always occurs, whereby interlaminar cracking or a                    
          generation of strain is controlled (column 2, lines 25-34;                  
          column 4, lines 9-13).  In addition, “by making the linear                  
          expansion coefficient in the axial direction of the CFRP outer              
          layer much smaller than the average linear expansion                        
          coefficient in the axial direction of other layers except the               
          CFRP outer layer, the linear precision of the formed roll                   
          after the peripheral polishing is greatly improved” (column 2,              
          lines 34-39).  Gomi states that the roll may be used as “a                  
          delivery roll, guide roll or printing roll for use during the               
          processing of a film, foil, paper, cloth or the like” (column               
          1, lines 9-11).                                                             
                                 Independent Claim 1                                  
               Considering first the rejection of claim 1, this                       
                                         -5-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007