Ex parte GUSDORF et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 98-1979                                                          
          Application 08/505,465                                                      


          claim 17.                                                                   


               Among other things, the patent to Stroh teaches (Figs. 3               
          and 9) openings 21 in the front face of vertical upright                    
          members 14 that receive lugs 55 of brackets 51 clamped to                   
          shelves 40.  As to the Zimmerman document, it discloses a                   
          foldable cooling/baking rack wherein shelving elements 20 are               
          positioned between posts 14 and 18.  The shelving is pivoted                
          to posts 14 (for folding the shelving relative to posts 14)                 
          and detachably connected to posts 18 via enlarged end caps 56               
          on shelving beam 22 received by openings 58 (large diameter                 
          portion 60 and relatively small diameter portion 62 as seen in              
          Fig. 3a) in the posts 18.                                                   


               When we set aside what appellants have disclosed in the                
          present application, it is at once quite apparent to us that                
          the combined teachings of Stroh and Zimmerman simply would not              
          have been suggestive of the particular adjustable shelving                  
          system of claim 17, i.e., a shelving system wherein each of                 
          the side brace elements comprises a side wall having formed                 
          therein a plurality of spaced openings having a keyhole                     
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007