Ex parte LANNERT et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-0525                                                        
          Application 08/590,859                                                      


          to a speed sensor ring (column 3, lines 15 through 25) that                 
          includes the feature of an annular toothed ring 38 (a magnetic              
          rotor) formed out of a non-metallic molded elastomer material               
          having the same formula as a sealing member 30.  The ring 38                
          can be molded concurrently with the molding of the sealing                  
          member 30 using a single elastomer formulation and single mold              
          cavity to produce the sealing member and the toothed ring in a              
          single molding operation.  Figure 1 of Hixson, II is described              
          by the patentee as depicting a toothed rotor constituting an                
          integral part of the seal assembly (column 2, lines 42, 43).                
          Once again, it is our viewpoint that one having ordinary skill              
          in the art would have                                                       


          understood the ring 38 and sealing member 30 of Hixson, II as               
          distinct entities, notwithstanding the teaching that they are               
          concurrently formed from the same material, and in a single                 
          molding operation to form the integral arrangement of Fig. 1,               
          for example.  As readily discernible from Fig. 1 of Hixson,                 
          II, the ring and sealing member are clearly spaced from one                 
          another.                                                                    


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007