Ex parte BENETT et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 99-0637                                         Page 5           
          Application No. 08/711,841                                                  


               The patent to Anderson also teaches in Fig. 4 with                     
               regard to claim 12,                                                    
                    a housing (48) having an opening extending                        
               therethrough,                                                          
                    means (24') positioned in a section of said                       
               opening in said housing adapted for retaining an                       
               associated surface (face of 24') to be sealed,                         
               a ferrule (24) having an opening therein positioned                    
               in another section of said opening of said housing                     
               in said housing and adapted to retain in said                          
               opening of said ferrule an associated tube [(12)] to                   
               be sealed therein,                                                     
                    a fitting (26) removably positioned in another                    
               section of said opening in said housing adapted to                     
               compress the ferrule (24) about an associated tube                     
               [(12)] for forming a seal therebetween, and adapted                    
               to force a face of said ferrule against an                             
               associated surface (face of (24') for forming a seal                   
               therebetween.                                                          
               With regard to claim 1, the appellants argue that                      
          Anderson fails to teach "the features recited in lines 7-10"                
          (brief, page 7), which we interpret to mean the steps of                    
          "compressing the ferrule around the tube to form a seal                     
          therebetween, and positioning and retaining a face of the                   
          ferrule against the surface of the device to form a seal                    
          therebetween."  We find that these steps are disclosed by                   
          Anderson in column 4, line 66 through column 5, line 9, as                  
          follows:                                                                    







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007