Ex parte BENETT et al. - Page 10




          Appeal No. 99-0637                                        Page 10           
          Application No. 08/711,841                                                  


          an opening therein positioned in the middle-right section of                
          the opening of the housing (jacket 94), a tube (15) and a                   
          fitting (second adjustment screw 105) positioned in the far                 
          right section of the opening of the housing (jacket 94).  The               
          tube (15) is positioned in the opening of the ferrule (95).                 
          The fitting (second adjustment screw 105) is rotated to press               
          against the ferrule (95) and compress it about the tube (15)                
          so that its inner surface forms a seal (95a) with the tube                  
          (15) and a face (the inner end 95c) of the ferrule (95) is                  
          forced against the surface (83h) of the device (83) to form a               
          seal (104) (column 7, lines 54 through 62).                                 
               We do not agree with appellants' assertion that Silvis                 
          fails to teach "the feature set forth in lines 6-8 of Claim                 
          12" (brief, page 7).  As discussed above and as clearly                     
          illustrated in Figure 6, Silvis discloses a ferrule (95)                    
          having an opening therein which retains the tube (15).                      
          Further, the ferrule (95) is located in a section of the                    
          opening in the housing (jacket 94).                                         
               We shall not, however, sustain the examiner's rejection                
          of claim 3 under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b) as being anticipated by                 
          Silvis.  In our opinion, the end of the tube (15), which forms              







Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007