Ex parte BENETT et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 99-0637                                         Page 9           
          Application No. 08/711,841                                                  


          adjustment screw (105) is rotated to press the ferrule (95)                 
          and deform it so that its inner surface forms a seal (95a)                  
          with the tube (15) and a face (the inner end 95c) of the                    
          ferrule (95) is pushed against the surface (83h) of the device              
          (83) to form a seal (104) (column 7, lines 54 through 62).                  
               We are not persuaded by appellants' argument (brief, page              
          7) that Silvis does not anticipate claim 1 because the ferrule              
          in Silvis is not positioned "in the body" as recited in claim               
          1.  As discussed above and as clearly illustrated in Figure 6,              
          the ferrule (95) of Silvis is positioned in the jacket (94).                
               With regard to the appellants' argument that the features              
          of lines 7-10 of claim 1 are not disclosed by Silvis, we note               
          that these features are indeed disclosed in column 7, lines 54              
          through 62, as discussed above.                                             
               Regarding apparatus claim 12, Silvis discloses an                      
          apparatus for producing a tube (15) to surface (83h) seal                   
          comprising a housing (jacket 94) having a hollow central core               
          or opening extending therethrough and means (tube 13 and first              
          adjustment screw 103) positioned in a left section of the                   
          opening of the housing (jacket 94) adapted for retaining an                 
          associated surface (83h), a ferrule (second ferrule 95) having              







Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007