Ex parte EMMONS - Page 5




                 Appeal No. 1999-1523                                                                                     Page 5                        
                 Application No. 08/839,065                                                                                                             


                          We agree with the examiner than claim 1 is anticipated by                                                                     
                 Rensch since the subject matter recited in claim 1 "reads on"                                                                          
                 Rensch.  We read claim 1 on Rensch's Figure 1  as follows:                       3                                                     
                          A connector, comprising:                                                                                                      
                          a first connecting interface adapted to be connected to                                                                       
                 and across a cross-section of a first beam (the radial arms of                                                                         
                 Rensch's junction elements 2A and 2C extending at the three                                                                            
                 o'clock position, the web of Rensch's junction element 2A                                                                              
                 extending from the three o'clock positioned arm to the five                                                                            
                 o'clock positioned arm, the web of Rensch's junction element                                                                           




                          3For convenience, we will make the following                                                                                  
                 designations: (1) the upper left junction element 2 is                                                                                 
                 designated junction element 2A; (2) the bottom left junction                                                                           
                 element 2 is designated junction element 2B; (3) the bottom                                                                            
                 center junction element 2 is designated junction element 2C;                                                                           
                 (4) the rightmost girder running between junction element 2A                                                                           
                 and junction element 2C is designated girder 3D; (5) the                                                                               
                 leftmost girder running between junction element 2A and                                                                                
                 junction element 2C is designated girder 3E; (6) the rightmost                                                                         
                 girder running between junction element 2A and junction                                                                                
                 element 2B is designated girder 3F; (7) the leftmost girder                                                                            
                 running between junction element 2A and junction element 2B is                                                                         
                 designated girder 3G; (8) the bottommost girder running                                                                                
                 between junction element 2B and junction element 2C is                                                                                 
                 designated girder 3H; and (9) the topmost girder running                                                                               
                 between junction element 2B and junction element 2C is                                                                                 
                 designated girder 3I.                                                                                                                  







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007