Ex parte MCKINNEY et al. - Page 2




                  Appeal No. 99-1962                                                                                                                      
                  Application 08/671,463                                                                                                                  


                  have been indicated by the examiner as being allowable if                                                                               
                  rewritten in independent form to include all the limitations                                                                            
                  of the base claim and any intervening claim.                                                                                            
                           Appellants’ invention pertains to a fuel nozzle guide for                                                                      
                  use in a gas turbine engine, and in particular to a fuel                                                                                
                  nozzle guide for improving bulkhead film cooling.  To this                                                                              
                  end, the radially extending ribs typically found on the flange                                                                          
                  of a prior art fuel nozzle guide are provided with trailing                                                                             
                  ends that are rounded off.  According to appellants, the                                                                                
                  rounding off of the trailing ends contributes to a reduction                                                                            
                  in “the formation of vortices . . . , [thereby] resulting in a                                                                          
                  lower risk of hot gases becoming entrained and causing thermal                                                                          
                  distress to the heat shield 58” (specification, page 7).                                                                                
                  Independent claim 11 is illustrative of the appealed subject                                                                            
                  matter and reads as follows:2                                                                                                           


                           2The bracketed numerals added to claim 11 are with                                                                             
                  reference to the fuel nozzle guide as shown in Figures 3 and 4                                                                          
                  of the instant application.  Consistent with appellants’                                                                                
                  disclosure, in paragraph (c) of claim 11, “each of said ribs                                                                            
                  having leading ends and trailing ends” would more                                                                                       
                  appropriately be --each of said ribs having a leading end and                                                                           
                  a trailing end--.  In deciding this appeal, we have so                                                                                  
                  interpreted this claim language, and the similar language that                                                                          
                  appears in each of independent claims 1 and 6.                                                                                          
                                                                          -2-                                                                             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007