QADRI et al. v. BEYERS et al. v. BATLOGG et al. - Page 18




         Interference No. 101,981                                                    



              There is also no dispute that the parties’ applications                
         teach the following other properties recited in the count                   
         relative the AB2Cu3Oy superconductive composition:                          
         Crystalline                                                                 
            Batlogg – p. 4, line 3                                                   
            Beyers – p. 4, line 7                                                    
            Qadri – p. 6, line 8                                                     
         Essentially single phase                                                    
            Batlogg – p.5, line 21                                                   
            Beyers – p. 4, line 7                                                    
            Qadri – p. 5, line 4                                                     
         Having a perovskite-like structure                                          
            Batlogg – p. 5, line 27                                                  
            Beyers – p. 4, line 7                                                    
            Qadri – see Figure 2 discussed at p. 7, line 23; compare with            
              similar illustration of “oxygen-defect perovskite YBa 2Cu3Ox”          
              in Grant et al, “Superconductivity above 90K in the compound           
              YBa2Cu3Ox: Structural, transport, and magnetic properties”,            
              Physical Review B, Vol. 35, Number 13, 1 May 1987, p. 7242             
              (copy attached to paper no. 40)                                        
         Exhibiting zero electrical resistance at a temperature of 70°K or           
            higher                                                                   
            Batlogg – Table at p. 11a, see examples 1 and 3 (measured at,            
              for instance, TcR=0; see discussion at p. 11, lines 18-20)             
            Beyers – p. 4, line 7 (e.g., “demonstrated bulk                          
              superconductivity”)                                                    
            Qadri – p. 4, line 20 (e.g., “having a transition temperature            
              above 85K”)                                                            
         90% Purity                                                                  
              The last remaining property required by the count is:                  
         “having a purity of at least 90%”.  Unlike the aforementioned               
         properties, this phrase does not appear verbatim in any of the              
         parties’ specifications and therefore raises a question of                  

                                         18                                          







Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007