MORRISON et al. V. MANNHEIMER et al. - Page 23




          Interference No. 103,197                                                      


          does not specifically suggest that this analysis can take the                 
          form of an oximetric analysis, as opposed to other types of                   
          spectrophotometric analysis, such as "fluorescence or                         
          associated phenomena of remotely located specimens in the                     
          human body" (p. 197, lines 14-15).  The only specific                         
          reference in Kapany to measuring oxygen saturation of the                     
          blood in tissue is the brief discussion (p. 197, lines 5-8) of                
          the non-invasive ear lobe oximeter attachment shown in Figure                 
          26(b).  Kapany does not suggest why it would be desirable to                  
          use an invasive technique to obtain the oxygen saturation                     
          level of blood in a patient's tissue  when the same                           
          information can be obtained non-invasively, using the ear lobe                
          attachment shown in Figure 7.26(b) (p. 198).  That is, Kapany                 
          does not suggest the desirability of measuring the oxygen                     
          saturation level of blood in a tissue specimen that cannot he                 
          reached using a non-invasive technique.  Nor does Kapany                      
          otherwise imply that the term "affected . . . tissues" (p.                    
          197, lines 12-13) may refer tissues including blood having low                
          oxygen saturation.  For the foregoing reasons, we believe one                 
          skilled in the art would not have construed Kapany's                          
          statements that "[t]he in vivo oximeter has been discussed at                 

                                        - 20 -                                          





Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007