Appeal No. 1996-3121 Application No. 08/115,783 decomposing and reacting a reaction gas containing carbon atoms, hydrogen atoms, oxygen atoms and nitrogen gas, a concentration of carbon atoms in relation to hydrogen gas being (A%), a concentration of nitrogen gas in relation to the whole reaction gas being (B ppm), and a concentration of oxygen atoms in relation to the hydrogen gas being (C%), the amounts of A, B and C satisfy the equation: " = (B) x (A - 1.2C)½ wherein " is not larger than 13 or B is not larger than 20, and wherein said carbon atoms comprise 99.9% or more of C or12 13C. 13. A synthetic diamond which is formed by a CVD method on a substrate made of a material selected from the group consisting of copper-tungsten alloy, gold, silver, copper aluminum, a ceramic and a synthetic Ib type diamond single crystal, wherein at least 99.9% of carbon in the synthetic diamond comprises at least one carbon isotope selected from 12 13 the group consisting of C and C, a nitrogen content in the synthetic diamond is less than 20 ppm, and a ratio of a peak height of non-diamond carbon to that of diamond in the Raman spectroscopic spectrum of the synthetic diamond is not larger than 0.07. As evidence of obviousness of the claimed invention, the examiner relies on the following references: Seitz 3,895,313 Jul. 15, 1975 Sakamoto et al. (Sakamoto) 4,725,345 Feb. 16, 1988 Yamazaki 5,015,494 May 14, 1991 A reference relied upon by appellants is: 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007