Ex parte ZHENG et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-0888                                                        
          Application 08/367,683                                                      

               We agree with Appellants that Dvorzsak does not teach                  
          using a double template to locate a single acquisition target.              
          A "template" is defined as an "overlay" and, therefore, a                   
          double template to locate a single acquisition target requires              
          the two halves of the template pattern to be fixed with                     
          respect to each other to overlay the target.  For example, in               
          the example in the specification, the two templates are a                   
          constant 10 rows apart (specification, page 14).  Dvorzsak                  
          determines the centroids of the positioning indicia 14 and 16               
          and identifies markable locations 12 relative to the                        
          determined centroids.  Because the document may be skewed at                
          an angle, the signatures 26 and 28 in Dvorzsak are a variable               
          distance apart depending on how much the coded document 10 is               
          rotated.  Thus, the system first finds the centroid of one                  
          pattern and then finds the centroid of the other pattern and                
          so uses two distinct single templates to locate two distinct                
          acquisition targets.  That is, the two signatures 26 and 28                 
          are not overlaid over the coded document 10 as a template, but              
          are overlaid separately over patterns 14 and 16, respectively.              
               The Examiner applies Ghazizadeh for the limitation of a                
          double template comprising two identical halves, as recited in              

                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007