Ex parte ZHENG et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1997-0888                                                        
          Application 08/367,683                                                      

          sequences are summarized in the table at column 4, approx.                  
          lines 52-57.  "Only the dark-and-light sequence of bands, not               
          the relative or absolute size of these bands, is used to                    
          identify the character."  (Abstract.)                                       
               We agree with Appellants' argument (Br8-9) that                        
          Ghazizadeh does not identify the location of the position of                
          anything.  The position of the characters is known.                         
               We also agree with Appellants' argument (Br9) that the                 
          slices 11 and 12 of figure 1A in Ghazizadeh represent scans                 
          across a character to generate dark-and-light sequences of                  
          bands which are then used to identify the character.  The                   
          sequences derived from the slices are used to identify a                    
          character, not to locate an acquisition target.  The slices do              
          not represent "templates" which are overlaid or compared with               
          the character.  Ghazizadeh matches based on the sequences of                
          light-and-dark patterns, not by comparing a template with the               
          character.                                                                  
               Accordingly, we find nothing in Ghazizadeh that suggests               
          using a double template to locate a single acquisition target.              
          Because all independent claims 1, 12, 23, and 34 call for a                 
          double template to locate a single acquisition target, which                

                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007