Ex parte MATVIYA et al. - Page 19




          Appeal No. 1997-1536                                                        
          Application 08/342,817                                                      



          invention that fall within the range claimed by U.S. Patent                 
          No. 5,356,849."  On page 11 of their brief, appellants express              
          their willingness to file the necessary terminal disclaimer                 
          "upon an indication of allowability with respect to Claim 10                
          and 11."                                                                    
               We consider appellants' expressed willingness to file the              
          necessary terminal disclaimer coupled with their admission                  
          that the carbonaceous chars produced by the claimed process                 
          fall within the range of the carbonaceous chars produced by                 
          Matviya to be a concession of the propriety of the examiner's               
          rejection. Since, on this record, no terminal disclaimer has                
          been filed we shall, pro forma, affirm the examiner's                       
          rejection.                                                                  
                                    OTHER ISSUES                                      
               In Paper Number 10, filed on November 27, 1996,                        
          appellants filed a notice that they had filed a continuation-               
          in-part of this application.  That application, Serial Number               
          08/757,212, filed on November 27, 1996, has matured to U.S.                 
          Patent Number 5,827,795, issued on October 27, 1998.  All the               
          claims in said process are claims to a process for preparing                

                                         19                                           





Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007