Ex parte LEWIS - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1997-1572                                                        
          Application 07/792,534                                                      


          ... .”  Appellant argues that Nakatsuka does not disclose the               
          storing of the handprint samples and the recognition of the                 
          handprint, it only discusses the storing and the recognition                
          of the handwritten samples [brief, pages 5 and 6].  The                     
          Examiner responds that there is no difference between the                   
          handwritten and the handprint data and the disclosure in                    
          Nakatsuka regarding handwritten applies equally to handprint                
          samples [answer, pages 8 and 10].  Appellant cites an article               
          by C. Y. Suen to illustrate the difference between the two, as              
          for example, there is a space between the handprinted                       
          characters [brief, pages 8].  We agree with the Examiner.  The              
          Suen article does not illustrate any difference between the                 
          handwritten and the handprinted data.  We agree that there is               
          a space between the characters in a handprinted sample as                   
          compared with a handwritten sample; however, from the point of              
          view of converting the handprinted data into vector stroke                  
          data, there is no difference.  If anything, it would be                     
          simpler to convert the handprinted data because each character              
          stands alone and the interference of the neighboring character              
          is minimized.  Next, Appellant argues that Nakatsuka does not               


                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007