Ex parte WELDY et al. - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1997-3269                                                        
          Application 07/918,519                                                      

          teach the claim limitation of reconstructing an image from two              
          quantized independently displayable representations of the                  
          image to construct an image with additional quantization                    
          levels.                                                                     
               We note that the Examiner has not asserted that either                 
          Chung or Rosen teaches combining two quantized independently                
          displayable representations of an image.  Nonetheless, we do                
          not find that either of these references teaches combining two              
          quantized independently displayable representations of an                   
          image.  We find that Chung teaches in column 1, lines 39                    
          through 43, that two image representations, the dither image                
          and the difference signal, are used to construct an image.                  
          However, we do not find that Chung teaches that either the                  
          dither image or the difference signal are independently                     
          displayable.   We find that Rosen teaches a system to                       
          facilitate transfer before and after data compression.  See                 
          column 2, lines 37 through 40.  However, we do not find that                
          Rosen teaches combining two images.                                         
               Thus, we find that the combination of Jones, Chung and                 
          Rosen does not teach or suggest reconstructing an image from                
          two quantized independently displayable representations of the              

                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007