Ex parte WANG - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1997-3793                                                        
          Application 08/294,235                                                      

               Appellant argues that Hata does not disclose an input                  
          signal raised to an exponential power of one of the gating                  
          functions g , wherein the gating function g  is greater than 1.i                            i                                  
          These limitations are found in all the independent claims.                  
               The Examiner finds (FR2) that Hata discloses an input                  
          raised to a power at page 32, section 4, line 5 ("1. literal:               
          x  ..."), and equations (13) and (14).  The Examiner furtherS                                                                          
          finds (EA7) that "x " at page 33, second column, line 14,12                                                       
          shows x  raised to the power of 2.                                          
                 1                                                                    
               Appellant responds that the notation in Hata, while using              
          superscripts which could be easily confused with                            
          exponentiation, has nothing to do with exponentiation (Br3-5;               
          RBr2-3).                                                                    
               Appellant is clearly correct.  The term x  is called aij                            
          "literal" of input variable x, where a literal is a                         
          propositional variable or its negation.  For an r-valued                    
          n-variable function F(X), X={x ,x ,...,x } is the set of                    
                                        1  2     n                                    
          n-variables, where x  takes on values from R={0,1,...,r-1}                  
                              i                                                       
          (page 32, section 4).  The term x  refers to input variable xj                                         
                                           i                        i                
          having the value j from the r values of set R, not x  to the                
                                                              i                       
          jth power.  Since each input x  can have one of r values,                   
                                        i                                             

                                        - 4 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007