Ex parte BANJYO et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1997-4387                                                        
          Application 08/308,963                                                      



          limited resolution of the CAD drawing program.  Therefore, it               
          is clear to us that appellants have not conveyed possession of              
          the subject matter of member 7a, as it is now denoted, that                 
          connects platen 4 to mold 7.                                                
                    Furthermore, it is our view that appellants do not                
          convey possession of a member 7a that "fixedly secures" the                 
          upper mold to the movable platen as appellants have now                     
          inserted in the specification.  Certainly, the drawings do not              
          convey to one of ordinary skill the manner in which the mold                
          is connected to the platen.  We are also puzzled as to how, if              
          the mold 7 is fixedly secured to the movable platen, the                    
          convex member allows the  upper portion of the metallic mold                
          to tilt during the clamping operation (Brief, page 6).  A                   
          fixed securement appears to be antithetical to tilting.                     
          Furthermore, with respect to claim 15, even if appellants had               
          provided support within the scope of    the jagged diagonal                 
          lines for convexity, it is not clear how appellants have                    
          provided any support for the upper surface of  the convex                   
          member to be curved.  For these reasons, appellants have not                
          provided descriptive support for the claim language of claim 1              

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007